Enter your ZIP code:

Auto Insurance & Generic Parts

If you were to hang around the inventory area of any major independent auto repair shop, you'd hear the statement, "Parts are parts." In short, generic parts, also called aftermarket parts, are perfect clones of those from the automaker, or original equipment manufacturer (OEM).

The initial introduction of aftermarket parts undercut the OEM prices by 30 percent. Even the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) believed the only place it mattered whether a part was OEM or aftermarket was under the hood. Many insurers decided that using aftermarket parts was one way to keep costs and premiums low. Even so, the use of aftermarket parts reportedly never rose above 15 percent of the market, despite the efforts of the Certified Automobile Parts Association (CAPA).

CAPA was established in 1987, through the efforts of the Auto Body Parts Association (ABPA), to improve public confidence in aftermarket parts. Although CAPA gets significant funding from the insurance industry, collision repair experts also serve on the 14-member Board of Directors and provide substantive advice.

Despite all this, in recent years several class-action lawsuits have substantially eliminated the use of aftermarket replacement parts.

The first major setback for aftermarket parts occurred in 1999. In the case of Avery vs. State Farm, a jury in southern Illinois found State Farm liable for $456 million in damages, and an additional $730 million in punitive damages, in a class-action suit involving use of aftermarket auto parts. The plaintiffs claimed State Farm Mutual Auto Insurance Co. failed to tell policyholders about the use of aftermarket parts in auto repairs, violating consumer fraud laws. They claimed also that using those parts did not restore the automobile to its pre-crash condition, resulting in a breach of contract. Although the award was reduced to $1.05 billion, the appellate court stood in support of the plaintiffs.

Such rulings have caused most insurers to avoid aftermarket parts, allowing automakers to regain a captive market and eliminating an opportunity for insurers, and thereby policy holders, to save money.

Not long after the State Farm verdict, Public Citizen, a consumer advocacy group founded by Ralph Nadir, condemned the ruling. They claimed that, with no basis in fact, the courts had created a virtual monopoly for OEMs in replacement parts. Worse, yet, this group asserted that this monopoly did not serve the customer, but rather cost the consumer.

Still, there are a few bright spots.

In February 2003, three class-action suits involving aftermarket parts-one each in Ohio, Washington state and Florida-were overturned or dismissed.

The Institute for Highway Safety conducted further studies, too. In March 2000, it again concluded that the source of cosmetic replacement parts has nothing to do with the car's subsequent crashworthiness. The test involved a 40-mph crash using two identical 1997 Toyota Camarys-one with OEM cosmetic parts and one with a CAPA-certified hood (the only part originally thought to possibly require OEM replacement). The CAPA-certified parts performed identically to the OEM parts in every significant way, the Insurance Information Institute reported. As a result, CAPA hopes its new term, "functionally equivalent," will be more effective in explaining the parts' performance than "of like kind and quality," the old term used in state and local laws.

It is likely, however, that insurers will be wary of using aftermarket parts in the near future, unless more judgments are overturned or there is legislation clearing the way for aftermarket parts.

CAPA produced model legislation introduced by the National Council of Insurance Legislators in 2002. That legislation was tabled until Winter 2005, so the status quo remains for now. Were this legislation passed, CAPA says, it would protect the public from both an expensive monopoly and substandard parts.

List of Articles
No. Subject Author Views
85 Rental Car Insurance: Do You Really Need It? youcomparequotes 17704
84 Auto Insurance: The Secret Weapon for Saving at the Pump youcomparequotes 18028
83 Getting the Cheapest Car Insurance in Your State youcomparequotes 16978
82 Play It Safe for Cheap Truck Insurance Rates youcomparequotes 17519
81 How to Get Discount Auto Insurance youcomparequotes 17781
80 Insurance for Van Lovers youcomparequotes 17523
79 Car Insurance That Fits Your Needs youcomparequotes 17180
78 Online Car Insurance Quotes in 5 Easy Steps youcomparequotes 17367
77 Getting Insured with an Online Auto Insurance Quote youcomparequotes 18383
76 Home and Auto Insurance: Sure-Fire Protection in Unsure Times youcomparequotes 17182
75 How to Keep Teen Car Insurance Quotes at Bay youcomparequotes 19423
74 Choosing Cheap Online Car Insurance That Fits Your Life youcomparequotes 17768
73 Auto Insurance from InsureMe youcomparequotes 17683
72 Car Insurance Comparisons Save You Time & Hassle youcomparequotes 18048
71 Car Insurance Companies & InsureMe Save You Money youcomparequotes 18439
70 Buying and Insuring a New Car youcomparequotes 16801
69 Compare Auto Insurance Rates youcomparequotes 17129
68 Safety Measures Lower Auto Insurance Quotes youcomparequotes 16635
67 Getting Car Insurance Quotes, from Beginning to End youcomparequotes 16728
66 The Car Insurance Quote & Ratings Factors youcomparequotes 17187
65 What's Behind Your Auto Insurance Quotes? youcomparequotes 17297
64 How Cheap Car Insurance Can Save You Money youcomparequotes 16639
63 How to Reduce Car Insurance Prices youcomparequotes 17174
62 Getting Insured with Free Car Insurance Quotes youcomparequotes 17368
61 Auto Owners Insurance & Costly Driving Mistakes youcomparequotes 16684
60 Auto Insurance Cost & Your Ride youcomparequotes 17180
59 How No Fault Auto Insurance Works--or Doesn't youcomparequotes 16956
58 How to Get the Cheapest Car Insurance youcomparequotes 16864
57 Selecting a Car Insurance Company youcomparequotes 17563
56 Finding New Car Insurance Following Cancellation or Nonrenewal youcomparequotes 17172
55 Get the Best Car Insurance Rates Around youcomparequotes 17413
54 Factors That Affect Your Car Insurance Quotes youcomparequotes 16450
53 Child Safety Belts Keep Kids Safe youcomparequotes 17116
52 Speeding and Car Insurance Rates youcomparequotes 16818
51 Not At Fault Car Insurance & Accidents youcomparequotes 16955
50 State Auto Insurance Becoming Available youcomparequotes 17434
49 Auto Insurance Gap Narrowed by Insurance youcomparequotes 17694
48 Car Insurance & Roommates or Family Members youcomparequotes 17267
47 PIP and No-Fault Auto Insurance Reform youcomparequotes 16965
46 PIP and No-Fault Auto Insurance Reform youcomparequotes 16869
45 SUVs: Minor Collision, Major Damage youcomparequotes 17420
44 Severe Weather Driving Tips youcomparequotes 17197
43 Avoiding Aggressive Drivers youcomparequotes 18059
42 Safety Tips & Car Insurance for Teens youcomparequotes 17113
41 Insurance for Cars: It's Your Choice youcomparequotes 17070
40 Car Insurance Quotes Save You Money youcomparequotes 17132
39 Finding & Comparing Auto Insurance Specialists youcomparequotes 18007
38 Safety Features Save Lives & Money youcomparequotes 16893
37 Curbing Auto Insurance Prices youcomparequotes 16434
36 Teen Auto Insurance youcomparequotes 16717
35 Car Insurance: Your Questions Answered youcomparequotes 16769
34 How to Buy Car Insurance youcomparequotes 17402
33 Vehicle Insurance: Covering Any Kind of Car youcomparequotes 16684
32 Truck Insurance for Your Pride & Joy youcomparequotes 16472
31 How Insuring a Used Car Can Save You Money youcomparequotes 17495
30 All-in-One Policies Insure Car & Home Together youcomparequotes 17302
29 Credit Scores & Car Insurance youcomparequotes 17891
28 Classic Car Insurance Protects Your Relic Ride youcomparequotes 16527
27 Reducing SUV Insurance Rates youcomparequotes 16855
26 Good Driver Car Insurance Rewards Safe Driving youcomparequotes 17372
25 How to File an Auto Insurance Claim youcomparequotes 17010
24 Avoiding Deer Collisions While Driving youcomparequotes 17477
23 Cheap Auto Insurance through Safe Driving youcomparequotes 16829
22 Auto Insurance Basics That Save youcomparequotes 17234
21 It's Official - Men Are Terrible Drivers youcomparequotes 18738
20 Car Insurance Quote Saves Money and Stretches Income youcomparequotes 17486
19 Auto Insurance Quote Heavily Dependent on Driver Behavior youcomparequotes 17010
18 Car Insurance Quotes Separate Fact from Fiction youcomparequotes 17270
17 How What You Drive Affects Your Auto Insurance Quotes youcomparequotes 17043
16 Cheaper Car Insurance in 8 Easy Steps youcomparequotes 17394
15 Save Hundreds on Your Car Insurance Without Switching to Geico youcomparequotes 16883
14 Your Options in Motorcycle Insurance youcomparequotes 16859
13 The Advantages of RV Insurance youcomparequotes 17232
12 Enjoying the Classics: How to Insure Your Old Relic youcomparequotes 34739
11 Insuring Your Teen Driver youcomparequotes 16995
10 The SR22 & Car Insurance youcomparequotes 16488
» Auto Insurance & Generic Parts youcomparequotes 17196
8 A Trip Gone Wrong: Summer Breakdown on the Road youcomparequotes 18331
7 Drowsy Drivers, Wake Up! youcomparequotes 16495
6 Cheap Car Insurance Protection You Deserve youcomparequotes 17872
5 Top 8 Safety Picks for Car Insurance Discounts youcomparequotes 17300
4 Drivers: 7 Important Facts about Texting That Could Save Your Life youcomparequotes 21398
3 Buckles: Use Them for Safety, Not for Show youcomparequotes 16801
2 Auto Insurance Quotes youcomparequotes 17264
1 Why You Should Give Thanks -- And Stay Home This Year youcomparequotes 17483
XE Login