Enter your ZIP code:

How No Fault Auto Insurance Works--or Doesn't

Auto insurers continue to promise consumers lower insurance prices, yet no-fault auto insurance still carries some of the highest auto insurance quotes in the nation—and the highest instances of fraud and abuse.

According to an October 2007 article by the Insurance Information Institute (III), no-fault car insurance allows each policyholder to recover financial loss from his or her own insurance company following an accident—regardless of fault. In fact, this system makes it appear as if no one is to blame at all.

No-fault car insurance limits your ability to sue another driver for physically-sustained injuries due to an accident. Typically, neither party in a no-fault state may sue the other for physical damage unless injuries are severe and/or medical costs are extremely high, meeting a predetermined, minimum amount.

This restricted litigation ability does tend to reduce the cost of your auto insurance quote and speed up your claims payments. Nevertheless, statistics show that the no-fault auto insurance system is not working.

Litigation costs for no-fault property damage, a major element in most accidents, remain high because some individuals may still sue if you damage their car or other property. There are also no consequences or personal responsibility associated with reckless driving, which edges your auto insurance quote up even higher.

"No-fault has failed to live up to insurers' promises of lower insurance rates," says Harvey Rosenfield, creator of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights (FTCR), a non-profit, non-partisan organization. "Lower premiums can be achieved by repealing failed no-fault laws and instituting strict rate regulation."

There are many reasons no-fault auto insurance does not work. Twice the number of people—both the innocent victim and the person who caused the accident—must be covered and paid for injuries requiring medical treatment than in systems which rely on personal responsibility. This creates incentive for system abusers and those who have no other form of health coverage to fraudulently increase medical treatment amounts—eventually costing everyone a higher auto insurance quote and yearly premium.

"Consumers should not be forced to continue overpaying for insurance to subsidize a bad idea that limits consumers' rights without lowering anyone's rates," says Harvey Rosenfield.

Findings from a national study of auto insurance premiums conducted recently by the FTCR include:

  • States with some form of no-fault auto insurance are consistently a majority of the highest-priced states in the nation.
  • Six of the ten states with the largest premium increases between 1998 and 2002 have mandatory, no-fault systems.
  • During those same years, auto insurance premiums rose 92 percent faster in no-fault states than in personal responsibility states.
  • Premiums are 19 percent higher in no-fault states than in personal responsibility states.

Under the no-fault system, consumers are left facing auto insurance companies' unfulfilled promises of dropped prices and increased accountability for system abusers. In addition, class-action lawsuits (those filed by a few individuals on behalf of a larger group) grow in number every day—and amounts rewarded by juries in these cases are sometimes ridiculously high. But as long as courts and juries continue to feed the no-fault system with monetary reward, unscrupulous doctors, lawyers and private citizens involved in fraudulent accidents and bogus claims submissions will continue to milk the system for all it is worth.

So what is the answer to a high auto insurance quote, sue-happy citizens and everyday auto insurance fraud? A recent Insurance Research Council (IRC) survey says 70 percent of respondents surveyed agreed that significant reform is needed.

"Every American must become engaged in…reform," says Edward M. Liddy, chairman, president and chief executive officer of The Allstate Corporation and Allstate Insurance Company.

States repealing no-fault laws are indeed seeing lower insurance rates and reduced system abuses. According to the FTCR findings, six states and the District of Columbia have joined in this effort since 1980.

"The bottom line is that you have to have participants in the system—voters, jurors, judges and lawyers—who have integrity and are willing to make the system work the way it is supposed to work, rather than take advantage of it," says Mississippi Supreme Court Justice Jess Dickinson.

List of Articles
No. Subject Author Views
85 Rental Car Insurance: Do You Really Need It? youcomparequotes 17653
84 Auto Insurance: The Secret Weapon for Saving at the Pump youcomparequotes 17981
83 Getting the Cheapest Car Insurance in Your State youcomparequotes 16928
82 Play It Safe for Cheap Truck Insurance Rates youcomparequotes 17417
81 How to Get Discount Auto Insurance youcomparequotes 17733
80 Insurance for Van Lovers youcomparequotes 17447
79 Car Insurance That Fits Your Needs youcomparequotes 17131
78 Online Car Insurance Quotes in 5 Easy Steps youcomparequotes 17317
77 Getting Insured with an Online Auto Insurance Quote youcomparequotes 18337
76 Home and Auto Insurance: Sure-Fire Protection in Unsure Times youcomparequotes 17134
75 How to Keep Teen Car Insurance Quotes at Bay youcomparequotes 19374
74 Choosing Cheap Online Car Insurance That Fits Your Life youcomparequotes 17718
73 Auto Insurance from InsureMe youcomparequotes 17635
72 Car Insurance Comparisons Save You Time & Hassle youcomparequotes 17996
71 Car Insurance Companies & InsureMe Save You Money youcomparequotes 18387
70 Buying and Insuring a New Car youcomparequotes 16759
69 Compare Auto Insurance Rates youcomparequotes 17090
68 Safety Measures Lower Auto Insurance Quotes youcomparequotes 16595
67 Getting Car Insurance Quotes, from Beginning to End youcomparequotes 16692
66 The Car Insurance Quote & Ratings Factors youcomparequotes 17165
65 What's Behind Your Auto Insurance Quotes? youcomparequotes 17278
64 How Cheap Car Insurance Can Save You Money youcomparequotes 16616
63 How to Reduce Car Insurance Prices youcomparequotes 17154
62 Getting Insured with Free Car Insurance Quotes youcomparequotes 17349
61 Auto Owners Insurance & Costly Driving Mistakes youcomparequotes 16664
60 Auto Insurance Cost & Your Ride youcomparequotes 17159
» How No Fault Auto Insurance Works--or Doesn't youcomparequotes 16935
58 How to Get the Cheapest Car Insurance youcomparequotes 16843
57 Selecting a Car Insurance Company youcomparequotes 17545
56 Finding New Car Insurance Following Cancellation or Nonrenewal youcomparequotes 17152
55 Get the Best Car Insurance Rates Around youcomparequotes 17393
54 Factors That Affect Your Car Insurance Quotes youcomparequotes 16431
53 Child Safety Belts Keep Kids Safe youcomparequotes 17095
52 Speeding and Car Insurance Rates youcomparequotes 16797
51 Not At Fault Car Insurance & Accidents youcomparequotes 16935
50 State Auto Insurance Becoming Available youcomparequotes 17257
49 Auto Insurance Gap Narrowed by Insurance youcomparequotes 17671
48 Car Insurance & Roommates or Family Members youcomparequotes 17249
47 PIP and No-Fault Auto Insurance Reform youcomparequotes 16945
46 PIP and No-Fault Auto Insurance Reform youcomparequotes 16849
45 SUVs: Minor Collision, Major Damage youcomparequotes 17402
44 Severe Weather Driving Tips youcomparequotes 17177
43 Avoiding Aggressive Drivers youcomparequotes 18036
42 Safety Tips & Car Insurance for Teens youcomparequotes 17095
41 Insurance for Cars: It's Your Choice youcomparequotes 17053
40 Car Insurance Quotes Save You Money youcomparequotes 17114
39 Finding & Comparing Auto Insurance Specialists youcomparequotes 17980
38 Safety Features Save Lives & Money youcomparequotes 16873
37 Curbing Auto Insurance Prices youcomparequotes 16413
36 Teen Auto Insurance youcomparequotes 16697
35 Car Insurance: Your Questions Answered youcomparequotes 16748
34 How to Buy Car Insurance youcomparequotes 17382
33 Vehicle Insurance: Covering Any Kind of Car youcomparequotes 16660
32 Truck Insurance for Your Pride & Joy youcomparequotes 16454
31 How Insuring a Used Car Can Save You Money youcomparequotes 17322
30 All-in-One Policies Insure Car & Home Together youcomparequotes 17211
29 Credit Scores & Car Insurance youcomparequotes 17824
28 Classic Car Insurance Protects Your Relic Ride youcomparequotes 16319
27 Reducing SUV Insurance Rates youcomparequotes 16836
26 Good Driver Car Insurance Rewards Safe Driving youcomparequotes 17353
25 How to File an Auto Insurance Claim youcomparequotes 16989
24 Avoiding Deer Collisions While Driving youcomparequotes 17459
23 Cheap Auto Insurance through Safe Driving youcomparequotes 16809
22 Auto Insurance Basics That Save youcomparequotes 17216
21 It's Official - Men Are Terrible Drivers youcomparequotes 18709
20 Car Insurance Quote Saves Money and Stretches Income youcomparequotes 17467
19 Auto Insurance Quote Heavily Dependent on Driver Behavior youcomparequotes 16992
18 Car Insurance Quotes Separate Fact from Fiction youcomparequotes 17252
17 How What You Drive Affects Your Auto Insurance Quotes youcomparequotes 17022
16 Cheaper Car Insurance in 8 Easy Steps youcomparequotes 17376
15 Save Hundreds on Your Car Insurance Without Switching to Geico youcomparequotes 16865
14 Your Options in Motorcycle Insurance youcomparequotes 16840
13 The Advantages of RV Insurance youcomparequotes 17215
12 Enjoying the Classics: How to Insure Your Old Relic youcomparequotes 34716
11 Insuring Your Teen Driver youcomparequotes 16973
10 The SR22 & Car Insurance youcomparequotes 16469
9 Auto Insurance & Generic Parts youcomparequotes 17178
8 A Trip Gone Wrong: Summer Breakdown on the Road youcomparequotes 18306
7 Drowsy Drivers, Wake Up! youcomparequotes 16477
6 Cheap Car Insurance Protection You Deserve youcomparequotes 17842
5 Top 8 Safety Picks for Car Insurance Discounts youcomparequotes 17281
4 Drivers: 7 Important Facts about Texting That Could Save Your Life youcomparequotes 21366
3 Buckles: Use Them for Safety, Not for Show youcomparequotes 16782
2 Auto Insurance Quotes youcomparequotes 17242
1 Why You Should Give Thanks -- And Stay Home This Year youcomparequotes 17463
XE Login